I’ve always been greatly annoyed at Star Trek for the way they treated Spock and Data. Neither are humans, and if I recall correctly, both are rather emotionless, either because they repress their emotions or because they don’t have them to begin with. The show goes as far as explaining that they’re not human because they lack emotions. And along the course of the series, both become more human by becoming more in touch (or developing) emotions. Of course, I think that’s utter bullshit.
Chimpanzees have the same range of emotions that humans have. So do cats, dogs, pigs, and a variety of superior mammals, including sea ones like whales and dolphins. Rats not only have emotions, they even laugh about them. So really, having emotions is not human at all. It’s animal.
Now, that’s not necessarily a bad thing. I for one don’t believe that we should ignore our animal needs. On the contrary, I think we should be in touch with our animal nature. But my point is, having emotions in no way makes us human. Ignoring them does.
I think that Data and Spock are by far the most modern, evolved humans on the Star Trek series. They are both driven by rationality, and while they can both develop attachment and perform acts of compassion, they are not enslaved by primitive, animal impulses. I believe that, ultimately, it makes them better than the rest of their crews. It makes them superior.
The sentimental attachment to animal emotions the Star Trek writers (and many SF writers) have displayed along the years is, in my opinion, childish. Reason is in every way superior to emotions. Even more so because it does not drive us to be heartless bastards. You can be reasonable and compassionate. You can be reasonable and ethical. There are perfectly rational reasons to being compassionate and to developing a strong ethic. For instance, you can reason that unnecessary suffering isn’t profitable to anyone and therefore must be minimized.
I suspect that this irrational attachment to emotions is simply a response to fear: the fear of growing up, the fear of taking charge—the fear of responsibilities. It’s a lot easier to be emotional. Being rational is a lot of hard work and requires discipline.
Now I’ve just rewatched the two Star Wars trilogies and I’m playing Star Wars: The Old Republic, and I must say love the Jedi way. It’s sensible and compassionate and ethical—it’s reasonable. Jedi behave in much the same way Data or Spock would, expect they are not despised for it. Yet, the movies do a good job of explaining where they all go wrong: they suppress the emotions, they bottle them up… and that doesn’t work well. It is, in essence, not very reasonable.
So what is one to do, then?
What I would like to achieve is balance. I cannot suppress my emotions. I have a lot of fear and anger in me— I’m an ape in a hostile environnement, why wouldn’t I be fearful and angry? Still, I would like not to be a slave to those primal responses. I’m worth better than that. I’m a human being, or at least I aspire to be. What I want is to be able to identify the emotions the second they manifest, and in a heartbeat decide what to do with them.
If anger flares up, I want to ask myself, Do I let it out? Will it be beneficial to the situation? Or, Do I wait and let it pass through me and only open my mouth again once I’m feeling calm again? I think that would avoid quite a lot of unpleasant and unwanted situations. How many times in my life have my decisions and my actions been dictated by anger? And anger is mostly a response to fear.
Yeah, I know. It would be swell, but it’s not going to happen overnight. It will take time and a lot of work. And I may not succeed at all. But I think being aware of this is a good first step in the right direction. It’s OK to be angry or joyful; what is not OK is letting any of that out in moments when it can be harmful to me or others. If I’m in physical danger, anger can be a great asset and help me punch my way out of a nasty situation. But it’s hardly ever a good answer to anything a friend or a lover would say. As a matter of fact, none of what anyone could possibly say should be reason enough to let my anger manifest outside. It’s got better uses.
So, that’s another big project: not behaving like an animal. Being more human than most humans currently are (including myself, by the way)—not by getting rid of emotions, but by feeling them only when the time is appropriate.
I think I can do it. It’s gonna be a long shot, though, because the universe’s ways of pissing me the fuck off are many.







